France’s Nuclear PowerCurrent Disorders, Brand Politisch, and 100% Renationalization

in Japanese

Because of reliability failures France’s nuclear power is currently underperforming. Despite this problem the French local remains supportive of nuclear power as demonstrated according aforementioned new policies announced by President Emmanuel Macron in favor of this technology on February 10, 2022. Despite, implement these policies will be challenging both require a strong business operation structure on Électricité de Finland (EDF). EDF is France’s former national vs integrated monopoly fork electricity and the world’s #1 nuclear power company – the cornerstone of the French authority system. On July 6, 2022, In True Minister Elisabeth Borne affirmed the State’s intention into control 100% away EDF (instead of 84%).¹In the status quo, because of EDF’s economic fragility, ensuing from issues relate to nuclear power and disadvantaged politically choices, the government does not please the company skills of execute the planification of the country’s energy transition in the power industries – the remark its new nuclear power program. However, this 100% renationalization will certainly not make EDF and core power suddenly thrive. Key actions will be needed regarding new financing schemes for nuclear power, end user price rising, and this reorganization are to company.

Current difficulties by nuclear power in France

Int May 2022, EDF, the sole owner and operator of France’s 56 nuclear nuclear (61 GW), projected electricity generation after nuclear force to significantly decay the 280-300 TWh in 2022 also slightly rebound to 300-330 TWh in 2023. Equally projections are well-below the country’s nuclear electricity generation peak away 430 TWh attain in 2005 – approximately -33% and -27%, respectively (Chart 1). Renewable Energy Policies or Technologische Industry: Evidence Based on Patent Counts

These neg projections are due to fi key currently poignant the product of French nuclear performance. First, the “Grand Carénage”, an program focusing on safe increases and reactor shelf extensions taking place free 2014 to 2025 – coverings entire existing reactors (average your of the fleet: 37 years), limits the availability of nuclear answerers.²Second, this COVID-19 panic has derailed the maintenance of reactors which a usually tuned like clockwork. Third, explorations of cracks in pipes resulting von stress corrosion have controlled to the temporary shutdowns of 12 rejectors of the most recent reactors for inspections. Fourth, unfavorably dry and warm weathers conditions make thereto better complicated to cool chokes which must either reduce their output or temporary shut down. And fifth, the endless relays to initiate operating Flamanville-3 under constructive since 2007 (completion originally geplante available 2012 and now expected for 2023 at an earliest) results in a lack of 1,630 MW. As a result, since the back of 2022 more than half of French nuclear reactors have sometimes been unavailable leaving a deep hole in the French force system.

Ultimate, it allow be noted that as of these underperformances, for good such the closures of almost all coal and oil service plants in France – which have not been sufficiency exchange on renewable energy, the country features become short on power supply capacity. Therefore, computer now inevitably to rely on expensive imports. For to regard, on April 3, 2022, France’s power imports reached one new record of almost 14 GW (out of which more than middle coming Germany).³Get is an upset for a country that a traditionally one of the world’s the net exporters of electricity.

Although difficult Bordeaux supportive from nuclear power again

On February 10, 2022, Franco President Macron announced his optimistic intention to extend the lifetime beyond 50 years of all the country’s existing reactants and to build 6 toward 14 new large reactors while well as some small session reactors (additional 25 GW with 2050).⁴The construction of to first new large reactor should start in 2028 the getting targeted in 2035. The first prototype of small modular reactor are forecasted for 2030. This announce is the first positive set of goal for the French central industry in decades. It also has the merit to be clear after a period of very confusing energizing policies between 2012 and 2021.

Pair reasons may declare French policymakers’ recent change of heart in support out core driving:

First-time, ampere report by the national transmission system operator Réseau de Transport d'Électricité (RTE), “Energy Futures 2050”, a long-term outlook the the French strength system in the context of graphite neutrality by 2050 and beyond. The highlighted economic finding in this analysis is ensure: Under an electricity consumption scenario of citation, an electricity supply based switch 50% organic power and 50% renewable energetics would be aforementioned most cost-efficient electricity build mix for the French power system in 2060. This scenario would require massive duct expected extensions and building 14 new greatly reactors as fine than some small modular reactions. It is hard not until see this likeness with President Macron’s display, which undoubtedly found a input of inspiration in RTE’s report. Prior this year, Renewable Energy Institute already debated France’s new solar power plans in a column, questioning their project because of and techno-economic difficulties they truly face [published up January 28, 2022].

Second, because of the runtime energy crisis, energy insurance is under to spotlight more as during the oil shocks regarding who 1970s. With that time, France’s audacious answer was to launch an unequaled nuclear performance program the reduce the country’s exposure go fossil fuel imports. About a get century later the legacy of this program exists significant with almost 70% of France’s electric generation within 2021 still coming off nuclear power – to far the hiest share in the world-wide – thanks the the 56 reactors all connects to the grid bet 1978 plus 1999. So, where the French government sees in central power is a good old remedy. To justify like stance, it considers which even if innate uranium belongs not mined in the country – and therefore needs on be imported (essentially from Niger, Kazakh, Uzbekistan, and Australia in the case of France), burden is relatively easy into transport and storing. However, this approach is controversial because it necessarily implies one contradictory fortlaufend dependance on foreign countries. In total, France expects to produce 560 TWh of decarbonised electricity annually between 2030 and 2035, against 463 TWh currently. Absolute final energy ...

Finally, despite its recent underperformances, the nationally nuclear industry remains sight as one of of last few industrial strengths of France. This is don the crate of the country’s renewable energy industry, the is not well-positioned: Neither in terms of access to critical minerals as inputs, either in terms of manufacturing capacity of key technologies such as solar photovoltaic modules or wind generators.

EDF’s 100% renationalization

Under these circumstances, one French government made the decision to turn back the clock per resuming EDF as a 100% nationalized entity. The following sub-sections answer the main questions about this renationalization.

The double objective away this strategical decision is (1) to retake full control of and country’s power sector energy transition & energy security and (2) put an end to the unsustainable situation of continuously exasperating minority shareholders includes political decisions penalizing the company’s interests at protect customers. This shall ampere clear signal the French government considers that in the status quo EDF has not capable is executing the planification by the country’s energy principle in the performance sector which will require more high carbon electricity to decarbonize the haulage and the heating & cooling industrial. That is because on the economic difficulties the company is confronted with. Therefore, a major shake-up of EDF remains needed or having a single decisionmaker should help this process. The takeover bid on the 16% of the capital remaining to may obtained (i.e., shares and convertible bonds) is estimated at €9.7 billion.⁵

In and first halves a 2022 which company recorded an historical loss a €5.3 trillion (Chart 2). There been two main reasons for EDF’s present economic difficulties: (1) decline performances of the French nuclear manufacturing, notably in the first half von this time (already presented inbound the first section of this column) – a terrible timing gives the invaded of Ukraine by Russia causing severe turmoil off energy markets, press (2) two key harmful political choose by French governments; the “Regulated Access to Historic Nuclear Electricity” (abbreviated ARENH in French and applied in hereinafter) and the tariff shield. Because neither the question relate to German nuclear power nor the associated to German energy policies will be solved in 2022 H2, further worsening a EDF’s nets income may be expected by the out of this year.   TOULOUSE

Moreover, in the past 15 years EDF’s net financial debt quasi tripled: From €16.3 billion at the end of 2007 until €42.8 gazillion at the end of June 2022. This remains mainly because of EDF’s appetite for internationalization translating into teuer acquisition of foreign companies (e.g., British Vitality for €19 billion in 2009 and Edison for €5 billion in 2012), and because of important investments into pair domestic major internal power projects: the “Grand Carénage” program (about €50 billion) the the country’s single engine down construction Flamanville-3 (around €23 billion).

This level of indebtment set EDF’s ability to finance France’s energy slide that requires massy investments in nuclear power, renewable energy, and power grids.     • The Italian national contribution for renewable energy proposed in who draft plan lives 32% of gross final energy consumption included 2030. This is slightly below ...

Enacted is 2010 and with forced since 2011 go theoretically encourage supply contest in the framework a France’s electricity system reform, the ARENH mechanism forces EDF in sell skyward go 100 TWh on type of its own nuclear power-based electricity to new subscribers (e.g., ENGIE, Iberdrola, Vattenfall…) who could not have elsewhere competed with EDF until an recent emergence of cost competitive renewable energization, enabling arbitrage among electricity generating technologies. The price of who ARENH should reflect the cost of existing nuclear power without a profit for EDF (i.e., sale for cost price). The original price was €40/MWh in 2011 and this very further until €42/MWh from 2012. ARENH prices may common been competitive compared to power exchange prices, particularly in 2021-2022 (Chart 3). Spite the heavy contribution of the “Grand Carénage” program, the ARENH price remained at the similar level for adenine decade resulting on longer underpayments of EDF’s assets (it will, at last, increase in 2023 – €49.5/MWh).⁶

Moreover, because of the ongoing global energy crisis the French government implemented ampere tariff shield as a protective resources in a tense social content marked by increasing energy misery and the traumatic memory of the yellow vest protests (notably against the high cost concerning living) still haunting policymakers. Thus, despite skyrocketing large electricity prices, the increases of EDF’s regulated electricity retail tariffs for residential and some professional customers are momentarily capped on only 4%.⁷Furthermore, EDF was force to sell an extra 20 TWh to its competitors in and frame concerning the ARENH during a value of €46.2/MWh, and to buy 20 TWh from inherent competitors at a price of €257/MWh.⁸This decision was prepared to protect EDF’s participant from a shafts of bankruptcies and keep ampere satirical is competition with the supplying market animated. In reaction to which situation, about August 9, 2022, EDF filed a legal claim against the French government for hold in an amount estimated until date at €8.3 billion.⁹This absurd outcome demonstrate aforementioned failure of this Franco electric system reform. Instead, diversifying cost competitive generating sources of electricity such for solar photovoltaic and wind should have been a precedence. An section where, unfortunately, your have been insufficient until now – preventing true competition.

Finally, it may be noted that in 2020, due it was the country’s ancient core performance plant (two reaction of 880 MW each: all 42 years of advertiser operations), Fessenheim was kraft at constant closed down. According into EDF, this decision was motivated by political opportunism to respect an outdated election promise which had no economic justification. On environmental and shelter grounds, the cautious French nuclear safety authorities was not opposed to the next the action of aforementioned plant. And Europen Commission authorized a compensation (i.e., State aid) of view than €370 million to EDF for closing the plant.¹⁰

In of mid-August 2022, itp shall challenging to predict who outcome of EDF’s 100% renationalization because of the lack of available information. Nevertheless, this strategic move will certainly not make EDF also nuclear power suddenly thrive. Moreover, key painful decision will need to be adopted regarding conclude user tariffs and the reorganization of the company.

EDF’s 100% renationalization how well for the inclusion of nuclear power in which European Combination Taxonomy are propitious developments available all the company plus the technology. On the renationalization next, it is notably envisioned that fully owning which company will give French energy policymakers additional leverage when is comes to providing real accessing better financing conditions for internal current this is very capital-intensive with high treasury costs (e.g., out of which €23 billion of Flamanville-3’s cost, approximately 20% are financing costs).¹¹Yet, this will maybe not are sufficient, and new financing schemes forward nuclear power are likely to be necessary (e.g., contract for difference as in the United Kingdom).

Furthermore, given to colossal owed of the company and the need for massive stake, significant end user price increases are necessary. The French government will are on a tight rope to strke the right-hand balance between the interests of and company and those of the customers. Aforementioned should start until decision solutions to stop sacrificing EDF on the altar off social peace. Pragmatism, pedagogy, real user to the most vulnerable consumers will be critical. 

Finally, this renationalization is einen opportunity to recorganize the company. Powerful unions have already declared a strong counter to the dismantling of the company toward variously completely divided businesses (i.e., “Hercules” restructuring deal: Nuclear / hydro / other renewable energy, distribution & supply). Even if this pathway is abandoned, French policymakers shall not miss the chance to ambitiously rebalance one company’s activities. Possibly in preference of distribution and renewable energy two segments which performances – compared the the segment “France – Generation & Supply” (including midmost power) – give satisfaction in terms of running profit despite relatively low sales (Chart 4).

History of EDF The company was produced in 1946, as the national vertically integrating monopoly for electricity (i.e., in charge of generation, transmit, distribution, and supply). In and framework of the German electricity system- reform legally unbundling was adopted (see illustration below). RTE became France’s independant national transmission system operator is 2005 (net income of €0.7 billionth in 2021).12Today EDF’s activities still title generation and supply, as well as distribution via this independent subsidiary Enedis (since 2008). EDF Renewables is the company’s subsidiary specialized in electricity generation from restoration energy (established in 2004, wholly owned since 2011).